January 29, 2008

UN Rights Chief Vs. Endorsement Of Arab Charter

Press Release: UN Watch UN rights chief must clarify endorsement of Arab
charter with anti-Semitic provisions

Geneva, Jan. 28 - In a letter sent today to UN High Commissioner for Human
Rights Louise Arbour, UN Watch urged her to clarify a recent endorsement of
the Arab Charter of Human Rights, which contains several provisions that
promote classically anti-Semitic themes.

"We trust that Ms. Arbour was not aware of its contents, but this must be
made clear, and the responsible person in her office must be held fully
accountable," said Hillel Neuer, executive director of the Geneva-based
monitoring organization.

FULL TEXT OF UN WATCH LETTER
Her Excellency Louise Arbour
United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights
Palais Wilson
Geneva, Switzerland

January 28, 2008

Dear Madame High Commissioner,

We commend you for your statement of January 27, 2008, recognizing the
current dangers of racism and anti-Semitism. We are concerned, however, by
your statement of a few days earlier, dated January 24, 2008, welcoming the
entry into force of the Arab Charter on Human Rights. We trust that you were
not aware of the blatantly anti-Semitic statements contained in that
charter, as described below. We urge you to issue a clarification on this
matter. We also urge you to hold accountable any members of your Office who
were or should have been aware of, but failed to call your attention to,
these racist provisions.

"Rejecting all forms of racism and Zionism, which constitute a violation of
human rights and a threat to international peace and security," forms part
of the opening preamble of the Arab Charter of Human Rights. Article 2 goes
further and calls for the outright elimination of Zionism: "All forms of
racism, Zionism and foreign occupation and domination constitute an
impediment to human dignity and a major barrier to the exercise of the
fundamental rights of peoples; all such practices must be condemned and
efforts must be deployed for their elimination."

As you know, Zionism is the movement for Jewish self-determination and
asserts the inherent and internationally-acknowledged right of Israel to
exist. A text that equates Zionism with racism, describes it as a threat to
world peace, as an enemy of human rights and human dignity, and then urges
its elimination, is blatantly anti-Semitic.

We recall that in June 2004, former Secretary-General Kofi Annan described
the UN General Assembly's 1975 "Zionism is racism" resolution--which was
repealed in 1991--as a low-point of the UN's record on anti-Semitism. In
1975, when that odious text was adopted, Andrei Sakharov, the late Soviet
dissident and Nobel Peace Prize laureate, said the resolution would
"contribute to anti-Semitic tendencies in many countries, by giving them the
appearance of international legality." We fear that the Arab Charter does
the same.

These provisions cannot be dismissed as harmless rhetoric. When Syria signed
the Arab Charter in 2006, its state-controlled SANA news agency expressly
cited these provisions. Agence France Presse reported as follows, on August
18, 2006: "In an obvious swipe at Israel, the [SANA] agency recalled that
the text 'considers military occupation, Zionism and all forms of racism and
foreign domination as a basic obstacle to the fundamental rights of peoples
and underlines the need to condemn and suppress them.'" In other words,
these provisions are hardly considered marginal.

Accordingly, first, we urge you to issue a clarification. Your January 24
statement described the text as an important step in helping strengthen the
enjoyment of human rights, and talked about the monitoring of its
provisions. We believe that even if the Arab Charter may contain other,
constructive provisions, nothing can justify any endorsement of a text with
such hateful language, language that has been thoroughly disowned by the
United Nations in 1991.

Second, we urge you to hold accountable any members of your Office who were
or should have been aware of, but failed to call your attention to, these
racist provisions. We note that the odious language of the preamble is
published on your Office's website
( http://www2.ohchr.org/english/law/compilation_democracy/arabcharter.htm ).
We also note that a newsletter published by your Office on March 15, 2004
expressly recognized "the language in the Charter related to Zionism" as a
"contentious issue." (This is available at
http://www2.ohchr.org/english/bodies/docs/Issue%20Nr%201+.pdf ).
Consequently, it appears that one or more members of your Office may have
been aware of the anti-Semitic language in the text, but failed to call this
to your attention prior to your statement. These individuals should be held
to account.

This is a time when racism and anti-Semitism are raising profound concerns
around the world. As you know, the government of Canada, in a decision last
week that was supported by parliamentary parties across the political
spectrum, announced that it will not participate in the upcoming Durban
Review Conference, based on concerns that the preparatory process would fail
to remedy the "open and divisive expressions of intolerance and
anti-Semitism" that characterized the original 2001 gathering. As
Secretary-General of the Conference, with responsibility for its
preparations, we trust that you will uphold the values of the UN Charter by
acting immediately and forcefully to oppose any such language if and when it
is introduced.

Again, we commend you for your statement yesterday regarding anti-Semitism,
and thank you for your prompt attention to this matter.

Sincerely,
Ambassador Alfred H. Moses
Chairman
Hillel C. Neuer
Executive Director
www.unwatch.org

UN Watch is a Geneva-based human rights organization founded in 1993 to
monitor UN compliance with the principles of its Charter. It is accredited
as a Non-Governmental Organization (NGO) in Special Consultative Status to
the UN Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC) and as an Associate NGO to the
UN Department of Public Information (DPI).

Your Comments

canpalnet-ottawa.org